We got our cake from Audrey's via the catering agreement with the Mansion at West Sayville. We met with Jamie at the bakery for a cake tasting, where we picked our flavors and gave her swatches of our wedding colors (my dress was green). We also later sent her a picture of our cake topper so they could match the colors with that too. Our cake design was simple (this is all that is included with the deal), but they matched the detailing well, and we got many compliments on the cake itself at the wedding.
Audrey's Fine Baked Goods
Connect With Us
About Audrey's Fine Baked Goods
Make your Long Island wedding reception unforgettable with delectable, custom-designed wedding cakes from Audrey’s Fine Baked Goods in West Sayville. Renowned throughout Long Island and the New York tri-state area for over 25 years, Audrey’s brings passion, quality, and artistry to every cake they create — from classic tiered masterpieces to imaginative custom designs that reflect your personal style and wedding theme.
At Audrey’s Fine Baked Goods, every wedding cake is crafted on-site using the freshest, finest ingredients, ensuring exceptional flavor and texture that your guests will rave about. Whether you envision a traditional multi-tiered cake, modern geometric shapes, or intricate sugar-flower details, Audrey’s experienced bakers work with you to bring your dream cake to life. Their custom wedding cakes pair beautifully with Long Island’s wide range of venues — from elegant ballrooms to rustic vineyards.
Beyond wedding cakes, Audrey’s bakery offers an array of sweet delights — including pastries, specialty cakes, and unique dessert selections — perfect for adding a signature dessert table to your reception. With a reputation built on quality and creativity, couples trust Audrey’s Fine Baked Goods to make the sweet centerpiece of their celebration as memorable as the vows themselves.
Planning your dessert should be as stress-free as the rest of your big day. Schedule a cake tasting at Audrey’s to explore a variety of flavors and fillings, from classic vanilla and rich chocolate to fruit-filled mousses — all customizable to suit your wedding vision and taste preferences.
Total 47 Reviews
My wife and I used Audrey's Bakery for our wedding cake and it was the most pleasant experience we could have imagined. We made an appointment with Jamie to visit the store in Sayville and had an opportunity to taste a number of cake flavors and potential fillings in a very relaxing environment. Everything was so delicious and the bakery smelled amazing! I loved their raspberry preserves and my wife loved their chocolate mousse, so Jamie said that combination would work very well together and the decision was made. Their selections and decoration styles were very clear and Jamie was so flexible with us as we chose our design and very upfront about the pricing. We paid at the store in cash less than 10 days before the wedding (picked up a few delicious pastries while we were there) and their crew took care of the rest. They delivered the cake to the venue (Bellport Country Club) on the day of the wedding and all our guests raved about how this was the best wedding cake they had in a long time. We wanted a memorable cake (looks and taste) and a seamless process and Audrey's did it all. We give them the highest level of recommendation!
My wedding cake exceeded my expectations! Audrey's did an amazing job. I had a 3 tier white cake with cannoli and raspberry filling with a buttercream frosting. I remember cutting into it and my husband giving me the first bite (well really the second because I fed him first) but I thought "Wow! This is really good!" Everyone enjoyed it. I also loved the simple yet classy design I chose. It was beautiful. I can't wait to have another bite when I open my first tier on Valentine's Day to enjoy with my husband. <3 Thank you Audrey's
An Audrey's Bakery wedding cake was included in our wedding package from our venue. We made an appointment to have a tasting which was easy to plan and fun to We picked out a butter cake with strawberry and fudge filling. They even took a swatch from my bridesmaids dresses to match! The day of our wedding, the cake was perfect! It looked great anday tasted even better! Usually I'm indifferent to wedding cakes, but Audrey's was delicious and we got multiple raves from our guests
We had Audrey's make our cake and cupcakes and they were amazing and very reasonably priced! Everyone raved about the treats!!!
Audrey's Fine Baked Goods Gallery
Awards By Audrey's Fine Baked Goods
-
Best of 2010
-
Best of 2011
-
Best of 2012
-
Best of 2013
-
Best of 2017
-
Best of 2019
-
Best of 2020
-
Best of 2021
-
Best of 2022
-
Best of 2023
-
Best of 2024
-
Best of 2025